At the end of May, the VKKS removed him from the chairmanship of the 6th Cassation Court in Samara.
The complaint was received by the court office on June 7. It is connected with challenging the decision of the HQCJ. The applicant is Alexander Efanov.
At the end of May, Mr. Efanov, by the decision of the HQCC, was prematurely relieved of his duties as chairman of the 6th Cassation Court. According to the commission’s press release, it checked the information received from the deputy of the State Duma of the Russian Federation Alexander Khinshtein in relation to Mr. Efanov.
And “recognized in his actions the presence of a disciplinary offense and for committing a disciplinary offense imposed a disciplinary sanction on him in the form of early termination of the powers of a judge with the deprivation of the first qualification class.” The decisions of the sixth meeting of the HQCJ are not active on the website of the HQCC and the exact wording is not known.
According to federal law, the decision of the HQCJ may be challenged within ten days from the date of receipt of a copy of the relevant decision. An exception is filing a complaint with the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation. It was her who was chosen by Mr. Efanov.
Recall that in numerous publications on his TG channel, Alexander Khinshtein talked about an expensive car rented from a millionaire friend, expensive watches, as well as stories about land on Podzhabny Island, which they tried to sell for 1 billion rubles.
On the eve of the audit of the Higher Commissioner of the Commissariat of Justice, already on May 18, the parliamentarian supplemented the list with information about the consideration in 2014-2015 in the 11th Court of Appeal, then chaired by Efanov, three cases in the interests of Khors LLC, whose co-founder since 2009 was Ivan Efanov, son judges.
The cases concerned the rent for three properties on the shore, which the company subsequently bought out. Khinshtein drew parallels with the history of the acquisition of Era LLC, to which the Efanov family is also related, land on Podzhabny Island. And he asked to take into account the influence of the family on the adoption by the authorities of the Samara region of unlawful decisions in favor of these commercial structures and to the detriment of state interests.
Yefanov said before the meeting of the HQCJ that “as soon as a decision is made that is not what the deputy likes, then it will be possible to expect the collection of compromising evidence, emissions in the tg-channel, slander, a commission and a presentation to the meeting of the HQCJ.” And he stressed that he did not violate any laws.
After the VKKS decision was made, Khinshtein stated that it does not release Efanov from criminal and other liability, which he intends to pursue further. So far, he suggested that the head of the region deprive the ex-judge of the title of honorary citizen.
In early June, Alexander Kurylin, ex-financier in the apparatus of the Liberal Democratic Party, ex-mayor of Zhigulevsk and businessman, once associated with AvtoVAZ, filed a lawsuit against Russian State Duma deputy Alexander Khinshtein. The plaintiff demands to refute the fact that he gave a bribe to Efanov in the form of an expensive car and an attempt to transfer money “under Khinshtein” that he did not receive. Moral damage Kurylin estimated at 3 million rubles.
Continuing the topic, Khinshtein published information that the Higher Attestation Commission sent an appeal to the Samara governor in connection with the revealed signs of plagiarism in the thesis of Ivan Efanov, head of the department of informatization of the Samara government and son of Alexander Efanov. He became a candidate of legal sciences in 2011 at the age of 29.
– Analysis of the dissertation, however, showed that more than 1/2 of the dissertation was written off without reference to primary sources. This is an ironclad reason for its annulment, if not for the statute of limitations: more than 10 years have passed since the defense. Nevertheless, the VAK asks the governor to consider this fact with the involvement of scientists, the parliamentarian stated.
Recall that earlier the Dissernet network community detected plagiarism in the works of Ivan Lobanov, the current rector of Pleshka and an associate of the speaker of the State Duma of the Russian Federation Vyacheslav Volodin. As well as the Minister of Economic Development and Industry of the Penza Region Almaz Khakimov. True, there was no public reaction to this information in either case.