Saratov officials “nightmare” the family of a disabled person. Vice-Governor Busargin is involved in the case.
The second letter to The Moscow Post was sent by Natalya Dmitrievna Shipitsyna, recalling that due to the difficult story that played out three years ago in the village of Teplichny, her father, Dmitry Lyashko, had already suffered 2 strokes. And from a healthy person he turned into a disabled person, because before his eyes the excavator broke the fence, demolished buildings, uprooted apple trees and apricot trees. The Moscow Post spoke about this in the first part of the investigation “Greenhouse conditions of Karev’s neighbor”.
So the new neighbor in the garden plot “gnawed out” part of the land of the Shipitsyna-Lyashko family. But after all the trials and trials, the offender cost little blood, or rather, a ridiculous fine …
In this story, it was surprising that ordinary people, without any connections, found themselves face to face with flagrant injustice, despite the fact that in the Saratov region there is a governor, regional and district prosecutors, police, courts, and the public. But Natalya Shipitsyna and her entire large family found themselves without help and without protection. And they’ve been fighting for justice for three years.
The correspondent of The Moscow Post in the Saratov region understood the land drama.
Land scandals at the governor Radaev
Before moving on to the private history of the Shipitsyn-Lyashko family, let’s take note of the fact that land scandals break out here and there in the Saratov province. And people involved in these scandals are not quite simple, with a position. So, a few years ago in Teplichny the passage disappeared somewhere, the road was buried. And in this place there was a site. And on the site – a house, a fence, a garage. As a result, neither the ambulance nor the fire truck could reach this corner of the village! And even the police were shocked when they arrived to disassemble …
It turns out that this was done with the permission of the head of the settlement.
By the way, at that time Roman Busargin dealt with the missing passage. By the way, today Mr. Busargin is the vice-governor of the Saratov region. But then, a few years ago, Busargin served as deputy head of the administration for housing and communal services of the Saratov region.
Roman Busargin. Photo from the site “News of Saratov”.
And neither the officials, nor the prosecutors, nor the police found any violations. It turns out that the Saratov region lives according to some of its own laws? And this is perfectly illustrated by the history of the Lyashko-Shipitsyn family.
Neighbor from the Moon
Even more than 20 years ago, Dmitry Lyashko, father of Natalia Shchipitsyna, began to improve garden plot No. 6 in the Teplichny village. Over the years, a lot has appeared on earth, because gigantic work has been invested in buildings and in the orchard …
And the neighboring plot at number 5 could not find a zealous owner in any way. The owners changed like gloves: they buy land, and then sell it.
Dmitry Mikhailovich Lyashko. Photo sent by the authors of the letter to the editor
But in the spring of 2019, a new owner appeared at site No. 5 – Dmitry Karev, the owner of Kaskad LLC. He immediately made it clear that he would not resell anything. Came to meet the neighbors. And he immediately presented a certain document that he, Dmitry Karev, could expand his plot by about 2 and a half meters …
But at whose expense? And what was this cunning document? It turns out that it was a paper, the act of land surveying.
But the worst thing was that this act was allegedly signed by his wife Natalya Shipitsyna for his consent to surveying. But the signature was fake, it was clear right away, although it soon had to be proven in court. This is the family’s surprise. The neighbor, who seemed to have fallen from the moon, decided to take part of the land very quickly.
“I advised him to go to the land management authorities and figure out this dark story,” says Natalya Dmitrievna, “and warned that I would go to court for protection. But Dmitry Karev began to bring down the fence …
This is what Dmitry Lyashko’s site looked like after Dmitry Karev’s “raid”. Photo: Natalia Shipitsyna
Karev took decisive action on April 29, 2019. Construction equipment demolished Lyashko’s fence. The iron garage, torn from the inspection hole, was moved, the cellar was destroyed. Then the barn was demolished. The damage assessor arrived the next day. The excavator at that time demolished the smokehouse. The destruction continued for several days.
Natalya Shipitsyna’s father, when raspberry and currant bushes were uprooted before his eyes, and then apple trees and apricot trees were uprooted, clutched at his heart. The new neighbor installed a three-meter fence along his new borders, contrary to accepted norms.
The Road to Calvary
But why did this purposeful neighbor choose the family of Natalia Shipitsyna? By the way, on the street where Natalya Dmitrievna’s father’s house stands, a former judge, a former deputy head of the administration of the Teplichny village and several other officials live.
“Capture” of the site. Photo from the archives of Natalia Shipitsyna
Karev’s neighbors, on the other hand, are a kind of family that does not seem to be directly related to the land conflict. But still, people are not simple, enter into power structures. For some reason, Karev did not touch their site, but began to torment site No. 6. Perhaps because the owner of the site is an elderly person?
The police came several times. But no action! The police department advised me to go to court. But why did people in uniform take the role of an outside observer? Natalya Shipitsyna several times personally took all the materials to the police: photos, videos, documents, license plates of cars and special equipment at Dmitry Karev’s station. The prosecutor of the Saratov region Aram Arzumanyan did not find anything reprehensible in the inaction of the police officers.
Prosecutor of the Saratov region Aram Arzumanyan. Photo from the website of the prosecutor’s office of the Saratov region
Natalya Shipitsyna was forced to apply to the Prosecutor General’s Office of the Russian Federation. And she asked to check the actions of the employees and leadership of the police department of the Saratov district of the Saratov region and the prosecutor’s office of the Saratov district.
In parallel, Natalya Shipitsyna addressed several times to the governor of the Saratov region Valery Radaev.
She tried to draw the attention of the governor to how his officials work.
Governor Valery Radaev. Photo: press service of the Government of the Saratov region
Persistently writes letters to the governor about the lawless unauthorized actions of c. Karev, which led to the demolition of the iron fence and part of the slate fence, the rearrangement of the garage from the installed blocks, the sheets of the walls and roof of the garage were damaged, the shed was broken, the brickwork of the cellar and the viewing hole of the garage were damaged …
All roads lead to court
Natalya Shipitsina had to go to court …
But what is especially interesting? Mr. Karev pleaded guilty. And he compensated for the damage in the amount of 170 thousand rubles. And taking into account his repentance, the lack of prosecution, the judge ruled: “The criminal case is terminated and a fine of 20,000 rubles is imposed.”
But there have been several reviews. When compiling an expert study by Bureau S-Expertise LLC, expert E. Manulik took the cadastral extract of land plot No. 5 as the main document. It is on the basis of the extract, which is the subject of the dispute, since it is this document that reduces the size of the plaintiff’s plot , the expert makes measurements, taking as a basis the coordinate points indicated in the extract.
The defender questioned the qualifications of the expert. He also drew his conclusions on the basis of illegally entered data from Rosreestr, which the plaintiffs just wanted to exclude. As a result, the court ruled to delete the data. True, for the fact that they were brought there, no one was held responsible.
But the second point, which demanded that the boundaries of the site be returned to its original place, was not satisfied. As a result, the former borders, which existed for 18 years, have not been restored. Due to the fact that two and a half meters of one plot “superimposed” on another, the family lost almost a hundred square meters of land. In fact, the land was not returned, there are borders, but there is no land.
From the reception of the governor Radaev, except for replies, nothing was sent, although this whole gloomy story has been dragging on for 3 years.
FSB intervention
And only the appeal of Dmitry Lyashko’s defenders to the Federal Security Service of the Saratov Region and the appeal to the media, in particular, and to The Moscow Post helped to complete the investigation of the criminal case. Still, Karev’s case went to trial.
But in the course of legal proceedings it turned out that the possible “seizure” of the land of citizen Karev was prompted by the unwillingness to be at enmity with other neighbors, who at one time illegally expanded their plots, using their own administrative privileges and levers. By the way, among them is a former judge and an employee of the local administration. Did Dmitry Karev decide to put pressure on an elderly person?
And when it came to compensation for damages, the Saratov District Court dragged on for almost 6 months, dragging out the consideration of the case on the merits. And in the end, I did not see a causal relationship between Karev’s actions and Dmitry Lyashko’s deteriorating health.
Capture of the Lyashko area. Photo by Natalia Shipitsyna
Therefore, on August 31, 2021, he dismissed the claim. Moreover, in addition to the terrible events with the seizure of the site, Judge Simshin also hung on Dmitry Lyashko the defendant’s legal costs – 10 thousand rubles. The daughter of Dmitry Lyashko managed to shoot a video about everything that was happening. It can be viewed here
And if the fact of arbitrariness in the Magistrate’s Court was nevertheless proven, and the plot of the culprit, by decision of the Saratov District Court of the Saratov Region of November 26, 2019, was removed from the cadastral register, recognizing the boundary case of 2005 as invalid, then the courts should restore the former boundaries of Dmitry Lyashko’s plot are not in a hurry. Recall that for 18 years the site number 5 was empty. And no one physically defended its borders.
But how did it happen that the land plots allocated in 1992, each 800 sq. m, today differ in size? And the supervisory activities carried out by the Rosreestr of the Saratov region revealed violations of land legislation: an illegal increase in the size of plots was established.
And if site No. 1 actually corresponds to the documentary 800 m, then the owners of the second site somehow increased their possessions to 839 square meters. meters. And is it not because they cut themselves a piece of state land, allotted for a fire passage? And if section No. 3 is increased by ten meters, then the fourth one cut off 68 meters from the empty section No. 5.
And since the borders were gradually shifting, Mr. Karev got a far from full-fledged piece of land, and instead of bringing the old-timers to clean water, he “flopped” on the old man Lyashko.
“The prosecutor’s office of the Saratov region does not take action and allows the Rosreestr of the Saratov region to violate the constitutional rights of my father,” says Natalya Shchipitsyna.
Natalya Shchipitsyna asks a reasonable question: “But if everything is legal and justified, then where did our land go? Why is 800 square meters indicated in the property documents, but in fact no more than 700?” It turns out that the court supported the arbitrary actions of Dmitry Karev?
Back in 2019, the court recognized the document “Landing Case of Plot No. 5” as illegal. And in 2020, he removed his coordinates from the USRN. And in 2021, despite the court decision that came into force on declaring it illegal in the court of the Saratov region, a false expert opinion was used. That is, the criminal acts of Mr. Karev have been legalized. It turns out that the Saratov region has “its own” system of justice, which allows to “legitimize” violations?
This is also facilitated by shortcomings in land legislation, cadastral registration, land management and land control, as well as improper organization of work on the execution of state functions in Rosreestr. And why is Governor Radaev so shy of this colorful story?